U.S. to continue troop withdrawal from Iraq - Instablogs
U.S. to continue troop withdrawal from Iraq
Steve Swint , Baltimore: May 23 2008
Made Popular May 23 2008
United States :

U.S. to continue troop withdrawal from Iraq

As the saying goes, “no news is good news” and so it has been with the Iraq conflict. The only time Iraq gets major news coverage is when things are going bad for America and the coalition. As a result, it is very easy to assess how things are actually going.

Using this ‘method’ it is quite easy to judge that Iraq is going quite well. I mean how much have we heard about Iraq in the past weeks? Very little.

So today, the suspicions of an increasingly improving Iraq were confirmed. General David Petraeus, the out going U.S. Commander in Iraq (leaving to take command of U.S. CENTCOM), announced that he expects to recommend further troop reductions prior to leaving his post.

The amount of troops expected to be withdrawn was not announced and it is doubtful to be a huge number, nevertheless, there are a couple of positive things to take from this.

The first is that it demonstrates the increased ability and aptitude of Iraqi security forces and police. They are taking a majority of the leads on raids and rooting out insurgents and are providing significant enough security for most Iraqis and for commerce and the economy to flourish. Even Basra, the site of one of the more recent major battles, is experiencing a pleasant period of peace and stability.

The second is that it demonstrates the continued weakening of insurgent groups like Al Qaeda in Iraq (AQI) and the Sadr Militia (the latter partially a result of Muqtada Al’Sadr’s cease fire). AQI is currently being rooted out of their last semi-strong hold in Mosul in North Iraq. This seems to be AQI’s last stand. There is no where else for them to go and they have been defeated in every location they have previously been.

It seems readily apparent that the “war” portion of the conflict is coming to an end. Since General Petraeus took command the U.S. military has carried out, with the aid of Iraqi forces, one of the most impressive military campaigns ever. Urban warfare of this sort is practically unprecedented in history, not just for America. It took too long for them to figure it out, but now that they have, they have nearly secured a military victory.

As Iraq becomes increasingly secure and safe the next steps are political rectification and economic development, both which have been actively pursued since the start of the conflict. However, as Africa can attest, economic and political stability cannot be attained without some respective level of security. Now that Iraq is acheiving that the sky is the limit for Iraq and the sooner U.S. and coalition troops can fully withdraw.

Add Images and Videos
Close X
Recommended Tags or Keywords
Search by Tags or Keywords
Selected Media ( You can Upload only Six media )
Sorry no picture found for this combination of tags. Try to search minimum number of tags at once
1 Stars
Mark
Perth, Australia
soon after the end of the Ottoman empire, the West has meddled in the middle east affairs for its own selfish affairs and it has done no good. US need to pull everyone out and let them have a massive region-wide war to sort it all out, let them face and settle the mess because this is what they are up to.

The middle east region needs a kind of bloodshed that Europe had in two world wars until they settle down to take our a solution. let them on their own and this will make them realize that war and conflict is their destiny and they will not settle down before they will be destroyed completely. let them rot why we are bothered????
2 Stars
Marcus
Manila, Philippines
I don' know what US is waiting for in Iraq. the coalition of willing is disappearing and it last ally, Britain, even has pulled out of Basara. this is strange that after so many casualties and international pressure US is hell bent on continuing in Iraq. Oil is too lucrative perhaps. But after so much of bloodshed and squandering so much money in “war on terror” now it makes a sense, even as Iraq is becoming serene, to go back home and save the soldiers, money and fatigue.
3 Stars
Cam
Brisbane, Australia
soon after the end of the Ottoman empire, the West has meddled in the middle east affairs for its own selfish affairs and it has done no good. US need to pull everyone out and let them have a massive region-wide war to sort it all out, let them face and settle the mess because this is what they are up to.

The middle east region needs a kind of bloodshed that Europe had in two world wars until they settle down to take our a solution. let them on their own and this will make them realize that war and conflict is their destiny and they will not settle down before they will be destroyed completely. let them rot why we are bothered????
2 Stars
Nkosipile
London, United Kingdom
US or UK ppl don't want war anymore. they want to bring their troops back. Still there are a lot of hazels due to politics. and this happened with Bush and Blair administrations. Bush shirked the responsibility to bring back the troops due to presidential election and at the same time, he had the option to put the choice on the next president. "War on terror" proved a nightmare for US and UK. sluggish economy and credit crunch made ppl miserable. Meanwhile UK Labor party paid for this in local elections and hopefully Republicans will face the same in Dec. elections. there is still a time for them to think over, otherwise the case will be the same for the Republicans as it was for the Labor party in UK local elections.
1 Stars
Chris
Toronto, Canada
i have an idea. why won't the America just install their own governments in every country they want to control, and call it "Democracy", the f**k... which really means "that the bloody US want to control everything and hide their markets"?

oh wait, they are doing that already. why they want to force their concept of bull shit democracy and freedoms on the other who do not like it at all.
2 Stars
Reuben
Brooklyn, United States
@Chris, Marcus

this is the abominable argument that US destroyed Iraq. I question what was good with Iraq before US started the war against terror. Saddam era was not for the liberation and freedom for the Iraqis. PPl blame US for everything. i.g. if US will not do anything in Burma or Tibet they blame us for doing nothing and if we would have intervened forcibly in Burma we would have again been blamed to intervene in other country like in Afghanistan and iraq.

We might have had the right or the wrong reasons but we are fully able and willing to accept the fact that we were wrong to support the attack on Iraq. This has got to be one of the larger foreign policy disasters in the history of modern US politics.

However, the question we are faced with now of course, is what do we do? If we pull out of Iraq the country will collapse completely. If we stay in Iraq odds are very strong that the country will suffer the same collapse but that it will take longer. I would say that maybe we should begin drawing down troops now and let the country collapse and reform itself.
1 Stars
Richard
San Antonio, United States
I agree that US war in Iraq was a mistake but does that mean we commit another one in halter scattering. priory Pulling of troops out of Iraq will make things worse than it is at the moment or one can expect.

this is the time to make Iraqis realize that they have to defend themselves if they want a free and prosperous society. Until they motivate themselves to do that, we have to try and clean up the mess that perhaps we have made. By overthrowing Saddam, we just gave them a fast-track to that end, only now we have to cover our own mistakes and at the same time pushing Iraqis to that goal too fast.
1 Stars
Eddie
San Diego, United States
It's very important that the occupation end before Bush leaves office. Bush needs to face the enormity of his failure while he is still in office. If the withdrawal happens after Bush has left office, Republicans will make political hay out of the situation by claiming that with just a little more time, Bush would have miraculously won the occupation and everything would have been roses.

What is most sickening, to me, is that if the withdrawal does not start during the remainder of Bush's term, Republican strategists will take their disastrous effort and spin it against Democrats for having done the right thing.
1 Stars
Steve Swint dryflypolitics.com
Baltimore, United States
Eddie,

What exactly is the failure in Iraq?

Is it a failure that it has taken so long to get where we are? Other than that, Iraq has been a success largely, just longer and more difficult than we thought.
Add your Comment